Main menu

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Public Health Textbook
  • E-Learning
  • Interactive Learning
    • Introduction
    • Finding and Appraising the Evidence
      • 1. Overall Introduction to Critical Appraisal
      • 2. Finding the Evidence
      • 3. Randomised Control Trials
      • 4. Systematic Reviews
      • 5. Economic Evaluations
        • Introduction
        • Scenario and Paper
        • Guided Critical Appraisal
        • Self-test quiz
        • Further Resources
      • 6. Making Sense of Results
    • Learning from Stakeholders
    • Obesity Care Pathway Support Package
    • Programme Budgeting and Marginal Analysis
    • Screening
    • Sustainable Healthcare
  • Teaching

Search this site

Home
Economic Evaluations - Guided Critical Appraisal

Please work through the following guided critical appraisal of the Economic Evaluations paper on the cost effectiveness of 3 type 2 diabetes treatments. There are 11 questions, and at the end you will be able to download a completed crib-sheet with all the questions and answers.

Click the link below to Question 1 to begin.

  • Q1 - Was a well-defined question posed?
  • Q2 - Description of the competing alternatives given?
  • Q3 - Evidence that the programme is effective?
  • Q4 - Effects identified, measured & valued appropriately?
  • Q5 - All resources identified, with appropriate units costs?
  • Q6 - Were costs and consequences discounted?
  • Q7 - What were the results of the evaluation?
  • Q8 - Was an incremental analysis of alternatives done?
  • Q9 - Was there an adequate sensitivity analysis?
  • Q10 - WIll the programme be equally effective in the scenario setting?
  • Q11 - Are the costs translatable to the scenario?
  • Q12 - Is it worth doing in the scenario setting?
Q1 - Was a well-defined question posed? ›

RSS feed

Syndicate content
Subscribe to HealthKnowledge

Popular content

Today's:

  • Section 1. The Sociological Perspective
  • Identifying and managing internal and external stakeholder interests

All time:

  • Welcome to HealthKnowledge
  • Public Health Textbook
  • Identifying and managing internal and external stakeholder interests
  • Dietary Reference Values (DRVs), current dietary goals, recommendations, guidelines and the evidence for them
  • Section 1. The Sociological Perspective
PHAST logo
Disclaimer | Copyright © Public Health Action Support Team (PHAST) 2011 | Contact Us

Company Information - Public Health Action Support Team CIC [registered in England and Wales under Company No. 06480440]
Contact | Telephone: 020 3479 5250
Registered Office - Sterling House, 20 Station Road, Gerrards Cross, Bucks, SL9 8EL
DH logo